How to Evaluate Goals Mid-Year: A Guide to Progress Without Perfectionism

You’re halfway through the year, and that familiar feeling creeps in. You know the one—that nagging voice asking why you haven’t checked more boxes, accomplished more milestones, or become the person you thought you’d be by now.

If you’re feeling behind on your goals right now, you’re not alone. Mid-year can bring up intense feelings of inadequacy, especially for high-achievers who are used to excelling in every area of life. But what if I told you that this moment of reflection doesn’t have to be about measuring your worth against an arbitrary checklist?

Learning how to evaluate goals mid-year is less about judgment and more about clarity. It’s about getting honest with yourself about what’s working, what isn’t, and what needs to change—without the guilt spiral that usually comes with it.

The Problem with Traditional Goal Evaluation

Most of us approach goal evaluation like we’re sitting for a performance review with the world’s harshest boss. We focus immediately on what we haven’t accomplished, creating a deficit mindset that makes everything feel like failure.

This approach is particularly challenging for first-generation achievers and women of color in corporate spaces, who often carry the weight of perfectionism alongside cultural and professional expectations. When you’re used to being the first in your family to reach certain milestones, or when you’re navigating spaces where you’re underrepresented, the pressure to have it all figured out can feel overwhelming.

The traditional “check your goals” advice also assumes that your January self knew exactly what your August self would need. But life happens. Priorities shift. Global events change our circumstances. Health challenges arise. Career opportunities pivot unexpectedly.

Yet somehow, we’ve been conditioned to believe that changing course is failure rather than wisdom.

Why Goal Adjustment Isn’t Giving Up

Before we dive into the how-to, let’s address the elephant in the room: the difference between healthy goal adjustment and avoidance.

Goal adjustment is healthy when:

• Your values have evolved or become clearer
• Life circumstances have genuinely changed
• You’ve gained new information that changes the relevance of the goal
• The goal was based on external expectations rather than internal motivation
• You’re prioritizing mental health and well-being over achievement

Goal avoidance might be happening when:

• You’re consistently choosing comfort over growth
• Fear is the primary driver of the change
• You haven’t actually tried to make progress
• You’re abandoning goals at the first sign of difficulty
• You’re avoiding accountability entirely

The key difference? Intentional reflection versus reactive abandonment.

A Framework for Honest Goal Evaluation

Step 1: Celebrate Your Actual Progress

Before you even look at your original goal list, take inventory of what you have accomplished this year. This includes:

• Survival wins: Getting through difficult periods, adapting to unexpected changes, or maintaining your mental health during challenging times
• Relationship investments: Deepening friendships, setting boundaries, or improving family dynamics
• Skill development: Learning new things, even if they weren’t on your original list
• Character growth: Becoming more authentic, practicing self-compassion, or developing resilience
• Behind-the-scenes progress: The unsexy work that builds foundations for future success

Write these down. All of them. The point isn’t to minimize areas for growth, but to get an accurate picture of your progress rather than a deficit-focused narrative.

This step is crucial because it shifts you from a scarcity mindset (“I haven’t done enough”) to an abundance mindset (“Look at all I’ve managed while navigating life’s complexities”).

Step 2: Examine Your Original Goals with Fresh Eyes

Now, pull out those goals you set in January (or whenever you last set them). For each goal, ask yourself:

Relevance Questions:

• Why was this important to me when I set it?
• Does this still align with my current values and priorities?
• What has changed in my life since I set this goal?
• Am I pursuing this because I want it, or because I think I should want it?

Reality Check Questions:

• What progress have I actually made, even if it’s not what I expected?
• What obstacles have I encountered that I couldn’t have predicted?
• What resources or support do I need that I didn’t account for initially?
• How has my definition of success evolved?

Energy Assessment Questions:

• Does thinking about this goal energize me or drain me?
• Am I avoiding it because it’s hard, or because it’s no longer meaningful?
• What would happen if I released this goal entirely?
• How would I feel if I accomplished this goal versus how I thought I’d feel?

Step 3: Make Intentional Decisions

Based on your reflection, you’ll likely find that your goals fall into several categories:

Keep and Recommit: These goals still light you up and align with your values. They might need timeline adjustments or strategy changes, but the core desire remains strong.

Adjust and Refine: These goals matter to you, but the original approach isn’t working. Maybe you need to break them into smaller steps, change your timeline, or modify the specific outcome you’re seeking.

Pause and Revisit: These goals feel important but might not be right for this season of your life. Give yourself permission to table them without guilt, knowing you can return to them when the timing aligns better.

Release with Gratitude: These goals served their purpose when you set them, but they no longer fit who you’re becoming. Thank them for the clarity they provided and let them go.

Real-World Application: When to Pivot

Let’s say you set a goal to earn a promotion in your current role. Mid-year, you realize that while you’ve been performing well, the role itself no longer fulfills you. The traditional approach might push you to stick with the goal because “you made a commitment.”

But what if that promotion would take you further away from work that feels meaningful? What if you’ve discovered that your values have shifted toward work-life balance, and this promotion would demand more hours?

In this case, pivoting might look like:

• Exploring roles in different departments that better align with your interests
• Researching companies with cultures that match your values
• Taking time to clarify what professional fulfillment actually means to you
• Focusing on skill development that opens doors to opportunities you didn’t know existed

This isn’t giving up on professional growth—it’s redirecting your energy toward growth that actually serves your well-being and authentic desires.

Managing Perfectionism in Goal Evaluation

If you’re someone who struggles with perfectionism (and let’s be honest, most high-achievers do), this process might bring up uncomfortable feelings. You might worry that adjusting goals means you’re not disciplined enough, or that changing course proves you can’t stick to anything.

Here’s what I want you to remember: perfectionism often disguises itself as high standards, but it’s actually fear of being human. Humans learn. They grow. They adapt. They make decisions with incomplete information and then course-correct as they gather more data.

The most successful people aren’t those who never change direction—they’re those who change direction thoughtfully and intentionally when the evidence supports it.

Red flags that perfectionism is driving your goal evaluation:

• All-or-nothing thinking (“If I can’t do it perfectly, I shouldn’t do it at all”)
• Shame spirals about not being further along
• Comparing your behind-the-scenes to others’ highlight reels
• Feeling like you need to justify every adjustment
• Avoiding the evaluation process entirely because it feels too overwhelming

Green flags of healthy goal evaluation:

• Curiosity about what you’ve learned so far
• Willingness to adjust based on new information
• Self-compassion when acknowledging challenges
• Focus on alignment with your values rather than external validation
• Celebrating progress even when it doesn’t match your original timeline

Questions for Deep Reflection

As you work through this process, consider these deeper questions:

• What would someone who loves me unconditionally say about my progress this year?
• If I knew I couldn’t fail, what would I want to focus on for the rest of the year?
• What am I tolerating in pursuit of these goals that I no longer want to tolerate?
• How can I honor both my ambitions and my need for rest and balance?
• What would it look like to be proud of my progress exactly as it is right now?

Moving Forward with Intention

Once you’ve completed your evaluation, resist the urge to immediately create a new, more intense plan. Instead, choose one to three areas of focus for the remainder of the year. These should be things that genuinely excite you and feel aligned with who you’re becoming.

Remember, the goal isn’t to optimize every area of your life simultaneously. It’s to make intentional progress on what matters most while maintaining your sanity and well-being.

Your Next Steps

Goal evaluation is an ongoing practice, not a one-time event. Consider scheduling quarterly check-ins with yourself—not to judge your progress, but to stay connected to what you actually want and need.

The most important thing to remember? Your worth isn’t determined by how many goals you check off a list. It’s found in how authentically you’re living, how intentionally you’re growing, and how much self-compassion you’re practicing along the way.

---

Want more insights like this delivered to your inbox? Subscribe to the Perfectamente in Progress newsletter for weekly doses of authenticity, practical advice, and community. No perfectionism required—just real talk about creating a life that feels genuinely yours.